12 large-capacity children’s insulation cup evaluation: 99 pieces and 389 pieces, where is the difference?
Last autumn, Stupid Dad has released 300ml of the small capacity of the suction cup. (Click to review:
10 baby straw flaming cup evaluation: this 299 yuan is not as good as 99 yuan
Some time ago, I also added a list of Little Tiny straw flaming cups (320ml) that evaluated excellent.
This year’s autumn and winter, let’s comment again,
Large capacity cup
When the baby is about 3 years old, after the kindergarten, she starts to use a large capacity insulation cup.
This evaluation, Stupid Dad chose the high sales of 12 large-capacity children’s insulation cups (550ml or more) in the market to conduct meticulous comparison, in order to provide professional objective purchase reference for the treasures.
: This large-capacity children’s insulation cup is evaluated as a neutral stand, and the daddy does not accept the realism and objectivity of the attempt to affect the results of the evaluation.
1, evaluation sample
2, evaluation indicator
3, first round: use performance evaluation
4, second round: safety test
5, comprehensive recommendation
The integrated e-commerce platform sales, brand awareness, fans, capacity, etc.
▲ sample map
The capacity of 1, 12 insulation cups has three specifications: 550ml, 600ml, 630ml, large volume and weight, more suitable for children aged 3 and over. Among them, 9 are 600ml.
In the 2,12 insulation cup, 7 are a glass of three-wheeled (straw / straight drink / poured), 5 is a cup of dual-use type (straw / pouring). The straw type, that is, contains a straw drink; straight drink, you can drink your neck; pour water, you will go to the cup cover.
The price of 3, 12 insulation cups is between 99 yuan -389. The price of printed and thermists is more than 300 yuan, which belongs to a higher price. Other 10 are medium and low-end prices.
First round: use performance evaluation
1 Insulation 2 Sealing 3 Drop resist 4 odor test 5 baby use experience 6 mother use experience
Second round: Safety detection
The first round of comprehensive score of the top 5 insulation cups, and then laboratory testing, the material safety of the nozzle straw, liner, and cup cover, including:
1 Volatile organic matter 2 total mobility 3 can be migrated heavy metal 4 potassium permanganate consumption, etc.
Finally, according to the results of the two rounds, it is recommended to give you a comprehensive recommendation.
The evaluation link is officially entered.
In order to examine the insulation performance of the various insulation cups under different environmental conditions, Stupid Dad designed four kinds of evaluation methods – national standard law, daily method, winter method, after test, the specific operation is as follows:
1. According to the national standard “GB / T 29606-2013 Stainless Steel Vacuum Cup”, the capacity is 550ml to 630ml, the diameter of the thermos cup between 34mm-94mm (manual measurement), the national standard method is tested for 6 hours, the water temperature should not be less than 46 ° C about.
The picture below is 12 insulation cups.
National standard law
As a result, it can be seen that the insulation efficiency of 12 insulation cups is in line with the national standard, and the water temperature after 6 h is 71.8 ° C to 77.2 ° C, which is much higher than the minimum value of national standard requirements.
Good boy, tiger, cup
The top three of the national standard law,
Baoguang, Babycare, Disney
Rank bottom, the maximum temperature difference is 5.4 ° C.
2, in daily life, the treasure mom usually wear hot water around 50 ° C, not the hot water of 95 ° C, otherwise the baby can not drink directly, this is also the recommendation of each brand.
As a result, it is visible, in the daily test,
Good boy, cup of bears, like print
The hot water cooling in the first three and 3h cups is not more than 3 ° C, and the hot water cooling in a 6h cup is about 4.5 ° C to 5.1 ° C.
Disney, Babycare, Thomas
Rank bottom, compared with the top three, 3 h and 6h insulation performance is about 1 ° C to 2 ° C.
3, if you stay in the winter outdoor environment for a long time, can the hot water in the thermal mug can be warm?
12 booming cups
The test results are as follows:
As a result, it is visible, in the winter test,
Like print, good kid, thermos
The hot water cooling in the three and 3h cups is not more than 4.5 ° C, and the hot water cooling does not exceed 9 ° C in a 6h cup.
Disney, Fuguang, Babycare
The column countdown.
4, the baby sometimes falls the thermal cup, you will not becomerated, will that insulation?
After the end of the 12 insulation cups, after the fall resistance test (the fall-resistance test is shown below), the daily method of insulation is carried out, the results are as follows:
After the fall-resistance test, the 12ured cups of warm cups were mostly slightly changed compared with the fall.
Slightly decreased, but no more than 0.7 ° C, the decline is not very large, the incubation efficiency is not significantly varied.
Comprehensive data, 12 children’s thermal insulation cups The score of the score of the insulation (full 5 points, the following):
1. Overall, good kids, tigers, like printed, cups bear, thermos, thermal insulation performance is better.
2, 12 insulation cups are not particularly large, basically can meet the autumn and winter season’s baby can drink “a hot (temperature) water” demand within 6 hours.
3. Compared with the evaluation results of the small capacity insulation cup last year, the thermal insulation performance of the large capacity insulation cup is relatively better. In addition, the more hot water in the insulation cup, the temperature is relatively better.
: For the sealant of the thermal cup, Stupid Dad has designed three simulation situations to test, the specific operation is as follows:
1. The simulation is placed in the bag or the baby is shaking, a cup of three-wheeled / a cup of two uses have been tested, and there is no leak in 12 insulation cups.
2, the simulated cup cover is not covered, 12 insulation cups
No water leak.
After that, the exhaust hole is designed, and the water in the 12 thermos cup will directly flow from the exhaust hole. A good child leaking is slightly slightly.
(Example: Cup Bear)
Remind the treasure moms, the straw type must cover the cup cover, otherwise it will be placed, and it may leak when it is put. A cup of three use straight drinks must cover the cup! )
3, the simulation opens the insulation cup after standing or shaking,
The case where spraying occurs, indicating that the exhaustibility is not good enough. Other 11 thermos cups do not have spray or overflow.
For the reason, good children’s exhaust holes are relatively small, although it helps to prevent leakage, but affect the exhaust effect, it may cause water to spray the baby.
Here is an additional reminder, some treasures will be loaded into boiling water in advance in the thermal cup (such as sleeping before going to bed), then wait for the water temperature to drink, but this kind of practice is not available! When the cup is loaded with hot water, it must be careful when there is a condition of the straw, otherwise it will be sprayed out!
After evaluation, the sealing score of 12 children’s insulation cups is as follows:
: Put 50 ° C hot water in the thermos cup, cover the cup cover, the cup is free to fall in two heights at 50 cm / 100 cm, and the cup bottom / side / cup cover is thrown 3 times, check whether to leak, zero Whether the components are intact.
Magic, Wukong, excellent
, The straw fell cup cover is open.
Fuguang, Thomas, excellent
The side wall of the holding cup fell.
Locks, Babycare, Thomas
The case of painting, sprinkling, and cup cover is two halves.
4, other 5 flying cups of resistance is better.
Evaluation, 12 children’s insulation cups score as follows:
: Refer to the national standard “GB / T 29606-2013 Stainless steel vacuum cup”, clean the cup with warm water, filled with hot water over 90 ° C, and the tightening cup is placed for 30 minutes, and there is no abnum.
In the 12 insulation cup, Disney can still smell a little metal flavor after cleaning, and the other 11 is basically odorless.
Baby use experience
: Simulation baby drinks water, opening / drinking cup cover, going out to carry, etc., experience your baby’s daily use is comfortable and convenient.
1, drink water experience
: In the 12 insulation cup, only the rich use is a cross-shaped nozzle, and it needs to be bitten when absorbing water, and it is possible to control the water flow to prevent it.
Others are straight-through (round holes) suction nozzles, no need to bite water water, children with children aged 3 years and above. in,
Slightly laborious, water flow is not smooth.
In addition, the Water plug is installed on the straw cup of Fuguang, Babycare, Disney, and the water temperature exceeds 50 ° C. The purple will become red, and the design is safer.
: 12 Insulation Cups, Wukong, you can be able to grasp the pouring angle when you fall, if you raise the water flow, you will be small, or even the water.
Cup of bear, tiger, music buckle, like printed, good boy, Thomas, flushing fluency is better.
: 7 a cup of three with straight drinking cup, the direct drinking tube is relatively large, the water flow is smooth, and the water is better.
2, open / turn cup cover experience
In the 12 insulation cup, a good child’s straight drink cup cover is not large enough, sometimes it needs to be manually opened.
There is no big problem for the other 11 insulation cups to operate, and the opening / off performance is relatively good.
3, outgoing experience
12 thermal insulation cups are equipped with a strap for easy access. Among them, like printing and good children have only straps, the other 10 straps have a cup set, and the cup sleeve can protect the cup wall to prevent scratching.
Babycare, excellent, Wukong, and cup sleeve, a pocket is also designed, and some small objects can be placed.
In addition, Stupid Dad also tested against the strength of the strap. The 12ured cups have experienced 50 consecutive efforts to pull, and there is no problem with the strength of the strap. It does not have to worry about break, fall off.
(Example: Good boy)
After evaluation, the baby experience of 12 children’s insulation cups score is as follows:
Mother use experience
: Simulation Bao Ma installed / disassemble the insulation cup, cleaning the insulation cup and other activities, experience the difficulty of the baby’s daily operations.
1, installation / disassembly
, The disassembly is relatively simple, rotate the cup cover, and then disassemble the nozzle, straw, and rubber ring. Installation.
7 a cup of three-purpose thermos cup,
The installation / disassembly is also very easy to rotate the cup.
, The difficulty of installation / dismantling has a certain difference.
Cup of bear, tiger, aater, good boy, Thomas, best-proportion, Wu children
, The water-in-water typing surface or is not rounded, or the area is small, and thereby causing the removal of the cover, it is not enough.
In particular, Thomas, wherein the surface unevenness of the bolt is uneven, the contact area is small, and the hardship is hard and the pain is hurt.
2, daily cleaning
The daily cleaning cups of the thermal cups need to be paid to the following places, otherwise it may be hidden.
In the cave cup cover, there is a narrow gap, and the inside may remain residual, and the hand is not inserted.
In the straw, the straight drink type buckle button, there is a gap, getting close to the mouth when drinking water, pay attention to the residue of liquid.
In the poured medium, the structure is more complicated, the depth is different, and the unevenness should be meticulous.
12 insulation cups
, Wukong, Yamble, Disney, Magic, Babycare
The cleaning experience is relatively better.
After evaluation, the mother’s experience of 12 children’s insulation cups scored as follows:
First round use performance evaluation summary
The above several performance tests have been completed, and the stupid dad is divided into the importance of the indicators, and the weighted average calculation is performed. The total score and ranking of the first round of the large-capacity children’s insulation cup are as follows:
Tiger, like printed, cup bears, the aater, good children, the first round of the first round of performance evaluation.
In the principle of excellence, Stupid Dad sent the top 5 insulation cups to third-party professional testing agencies, and laboratory tests for material safety.
Laboratory safety detection
None absorption, liner, poured cup cover
Because they have the highest level of liquid contact with the baby’s mouth and cups. Specific test indicators include:
: 1 Total migration: Detection has a non-volatile material migration precipitation and content; 2 Volatile organic matter: Test whether there is a volatile organic matter migration precipitation and content.
: 1 Heavy metal arsenic cadmium lead chromium nickel-chromium nickel: detection whether there is arsenic cadmium lead chromium nickel migration precipitation and content.
Porkwater cup cover
: 1 total mobility; 2 potassium permanganate consumption: Detection has a precipitation and content of soluble organic matter migration.
The following is a five-child thermal insulation cup safety test results:
1, nozzle straw
1 Tiger, like the nozzle of the ratio of the ratio of the total mobility, the detection value is 24mg / kg, 26mg / kg, less than the national standard limit 60mg / kg, which is in line with the national standard.
The nozzle straw detection of 25 insulation cups detected volatile organic matter. The indicator is not limited in the national standard of the insulation cup, which is based on “GB4806.2-2015 Food Safety National Standard Nuzzle”, and the sample is relatively stricter.
Among them, a good child, the arson, and the volatile organic value of the like is smaller than the “nip national standard”, and the situation is ideal.
Tiger, the volatile organic test value of the cup gear bears is slightly out of the “nip national standard” limit. Considering that the large capacity insulation cup is mainly suitable for 3 years old and above the baby, and is one of a variety of drinking water. Stupet Dad thinks that the impact is not too large, but it will deduct it.
1 Good child’s liner detection heavy metal nickel migration, detected 0.014 mg / kg, smaller than the national standard limit 0.5mg / kg, in accordance with the national standard.
2 Other 4 insulation cups of heavy metal specific migration test results are: unselected.
3, poured cup cover
First round: use performance evaluation
Second round: Safety detection
The picture below is 12 insulation cups.
12 booming cups
12 booming cups
(Example: Cup Bear)
1 Good child’s cup cover detected a total mobility of 24 mg / kg, and the cup cover of the printed cup was detected by 2 mg / kg, which was less than 60mg / kg, 10mg / kg, 10mg / kg, which was less than the national standard requirements.
2 The total mobility of the other three insulation cup caps, the test results of potassium permanganate are: unselected.
(P.S. Test report Original text, please check in the “Baby Review” WeChat public number, enter keyword “brand name + test report”, such as “Cup Test Report”, “Tiger Test Report”)
Comprehensive test results, the second round of safety scores of 5 large-capacity children’s insulation cups are as follows:
Comprehensive two-wheeled evaluation results, Stupid Dad conducted weighted averages for two rounds of evaluation, the final score and ranking of 5 large-capacity children’s insulation cups:
Since the final score of 5 insulation cups is relatively close, the stupid dad collects them as recommended products.
The price of 5 insulation cups is between 198 yuan – 389 yuan. You can choose from need to choose from the advantages and disadvantages of each product, cost performance, and baby usage habits.
1. Thermos FFG-603WF
Reference price: 338 yuan / 600ml
: The insulation performance ranks first five; better sealing performance (pay attention to the cavity to cover the cup), there is no problem in the normal use; a cup of dual-use type (pipette, pouring water); baby drink water experience Mother installation / disassembly and cleaning is more convenient; laboratory safety detection is better.
2. 印 SC-ZT60-BA
Reference price: 389 yuan / 600ml
: Comprehensive manifestation of thermal insulation performance, better sealing (pay attention to the capsule needle); cold resistance; a cup of dual-use type (pipette, pouring water); unwritten cup set, baby out experience General; mother installation / disassembly and cleaning is more convenient; various safety tests in laboratory are in line with national standards.
3. Cup bear RT104-630
Reference price: 198 yuan / 630ml
: The insulation performance ranks fourth; better sealing (pay attention to the cavity to cover the cup); the fall resistance is better; a cup of three use; the baby’s experience is good; The volatile organic matter content of the nozzle straw is detected is slightly high; the overall price is relatively high.
4. Tiger MBJ-C06C
Reference price: 269 yuan / 600ml
: The insulation performance is ranked second; the resistance and sealing are better (note the cap needle need to cover the cup); a cup of dual-use type (straw, pouring water); baby daily use is more convenient and comfortable; Mom Installation / The difficulty of disassembly / cleaning is slightly inferior; the laboratory detection of the volatile organic content of the nozzle straw is slightly high.
5. Good boy h80224
Reference price: 199 yuan / 600ml
: The overall insulation is optimal; the sealed exhaust property is generally, the straw type may spray the water / overwater; the fall resistance is better; a cup of three use; unwolding cup cover, baby open cover and out the experience, the experience of the mother Slightly; various safety tests in the laboratory are in line with the national standard, and the overall price is relatively high.
The detection samples are randomly purchased. The detection data of different batch products may volatile. The test results are only responsible for the delivery batch product, but the dad believes that the responsible enterprise product quality should be as stable as much as possible.
The above is a total analysis of this large-capacity child warming cup evaluation.
Ok, this issue is over here. If you think the article is useful, please forward support!
If you want to query more related articles, or have problems to consult, welcome to pay attention to “Baby Review” WeChat public number (ID: baobaopingce) and leave a message in the background, and the dad will answer you separately.
1,32 national line version of milk powder comprehensive evaluation
2,38 domestic milk powder comprehensive evaluation
3, love his beauty five major version of milk powder comprehensive evaluation
4, Mei Su Jiaer 23 milk powder comprehensive assessment
5, Mead Johnson 33 milk powder comprehensive evaluation
6, A2 milk powder comprehensive evaluation
7, 66 bottle & pacifier evaluation
8. Baby sunscreen assessment
9, baby mosquito repellent product big evaluation
10, 22 baby rice noodle evaluation
11, 13 baby vitamin D evaluation
12, 20 pull pants evaluation
Please check in the “Baby Review” header history article; or pay attention to the “baby evaluation” WeChat public number (ID: baobaoGce), enter the corresponding keyword query in the background.
For “Baby Review”, please click “Learn more” in the bottom below. Welcome to the stupid father to reward.
Welcome to “baby evaluation”. 7 years of product comparison experience, no speculation, with scientific rational stupid methods to provide reliable consumption recommendations.